Bob wrote this in 2011. Weights and the darts we stock have changed a little since; see Darts for what we make today.
At Thunderbird Atlatl we make atlatl darts for lots of different purposes. Five-foot, 5-ounce ash darts may not interest someone who wants to compete in the International Standard Accuracy Contest, but when it comes to summer camp or Boy Scouts with groups of 8 to 12 year old participants, nothing works better. They are both durable and affordable. Our 6-foot, 6-ounce ash darts likewise are great for the younger set and more mature beginning atlatlists for some of the same reasons. These are the dart shafts that are included in our Thunderbird Atlatl kits.
The 3 to 5 ounce bamboo darts that we make are anywhere from about 5 to 8 feet or longer, with conical copper points. They are fantastic for competition because they fly straight and true. I don’t think there is a natural material better than the Yadake bamboo we use for making these world-class competition darts. Our formula for building these bamboo darts came from adapting methods developed by Japanese arrow makers. The copper points we use came from a study of artifacts of the Old Copper Culture of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. While eclectic in traditional but cross-culture themes, these darts really perform. Some of the highest scores in the International Standard Accuracy Contest have been achieved with bamboo darts.
We make lighter 7-foot darts from Engelmann spruce and Douglas fir from British Columbia for better accuracy at longer distances, but they are not as good for penetration. We make darts as short as 4 feet that weigh less than an ounce for distance throwing, for those who want to try their hand at an interesting part of the atlatl sport.
Start with your goal
It is important to consider what your goals are when you choose your atlatls and darts.
- Our 5-foot darts at 5 ounces are designed for younger beginning atlatlists.
- The 6-foot, 6-ounce ash darts are a good all-around dart for practice and stump shooting. They have been used successfully for hunting by younger or smaller atlatlists.
- The principle: longer darts are more accurate, heavier darts are better for penetration, and lighter, smaller darts are good for distance. Longer, lighter darts are good for target shooting.
Heavy darts for hunting
The reason I make heavier ash darts is to get the penetration needed to kill large game animals. Heavy wood darts are not very good for shooting long distances. They are useful at short distances, up to about 15 meters, and at that range and under they are very accurate.
An 8-ounce dart shot by my friend Leggs at Sertsie’s Farm went completely through the skull of a boar, killing the animal instantly. The point ended up in the chest cavity with more than 14 inches of penetration after going through skull bone twice. If you hunt wild boar enough with atlatls you will need to be able to do this, or you will regret it. A wild boar once lifted me completely off the ground and flipped me like a flicked booger.
While a bamboo dart with a foreshaft might work for hunting, the economics of it do not work for me. Bamboo hunting darts end up costing $35 to $50 each. When you consider all the work it takes to make one, and the fact that they often end up broken after a hunt, I find it hard to justify that cost when there are economical alternatives I can make in large enough quantities to meet my customers’ demand.
Consistent bamboo darts, like you need to hunt with, are difficult to make from a material with so many variables. It takes a lot of time harvesting, sorting and testing the raw material. To get good bamboo shafts you need to know when to pick them and how to cure them properly, or you will have problems getting and keeping them straight. After a half-hour job straightening a bamboo shaft, you have to measure the weight, spine, diameter at both ends, length, wall thickness and elasticity, and sort the shafts by these criteria. Then you have to build foreshafts and nock dimples. This doesn’t mean I don’t like bamboo darts; it’s just not my choice for hunting. I love bamboo darts for target shooting.
For hunting, besides the original 8-ounce, 7-foot ash shaft, I make six- and seven-foot tapered ash darts that weigh about 6 and 7 ounces, heat-treated for hunting. They have good penetration and are easy to shoot. They are more aerodynamic than the original cylindrical darts, so they fly straighter, yet they still carry enough mass to penetrate any big game animal.
In my hunting over the last 20 years, good killing shots on big game were almost always made with heavier darts. I have seen many hits on deer and wild boar with light darts that simply did not get the job done.
Why some old darts were short
Different cultures used different darts for different reasons. Some of the darts used by Native Alaskans are short. I have provided some Native Alaskans with short 53-inch tapered darts that replicate darts their ancestors used. I was curious, so I tried them. I couldn’t get them to fly very accurately until I used one in a canoe to shoot straight down into the water. Then I realized that most of the darts used by Native Alaskans who lived by the sea were for shooting aquatic animals, from fairly short atlatls. A longer dart used by a kayaker would already be in the water before the shot.
The reason I couldn’t get them to fly accurately was that I couldn’t see much except the tip of the dart. Without that reference it is hard to tell which way the dart is aiming. So how were these darts used with accuracy? I reasoned that they were held almost straight up, because they were mainly thrown at things beneath the water from a kayak, which gave the thrower a full view of the dart. When the dart is held horizontally, most of its length disappears behind the thrower’s head.
I have seen lots of people try short darts, but when accuracy is the main issue they eventually go to longer darts. It is my customers who decide what length of dart they want to use, and they overwhelmingly choose longer darts.
