In 2005 and 2006 the Pennsylvania Game Commission considered making the atlatl legal for deer hunting, and Bob wrote to commissioners, legislators, reporters and hunting forums. This post collects his own words from that winter, lightly edited. Update, 2026: In January 2006 the Game Commission gave preliminary approval to atlatl deer hunting, against its staff’s advice, but the proposal was shelved that spring and never took effect. Pennsylvania still does not allow atlatl hunting. Bob still believes the Commission should reconsider, now that several other states allow the atlatl for hunting.
Why I hunt with the atlatl
I have hunted with the atlatl every year since 1991. Every year I got either a wild boar, a deer or both. I’m not the most coordinated guy you have ever seen, and I was always the last guy picked to play ball in school, but I am good enough with an atlatl to kill deer.
I also fish with the atlatl, and I have gotten a lot of fish with it. Fish are a lot smaller than deer, but I still manage to get them even though I am throwing off a rocking boat. I showed a guy in Florida how to use an atlatl for shooting fish, and he was consistently getting fish about the size of hot dogs. Hitting a deer with an atlatl is no problem. Killing a deer with an atlatl is no problem. Finding a place to hunt where it is legal is the problem.
I love to hunt with the atlatl because I get to watch the game for a longer time, until it gets close enough for my shot. Those who picture my favorite kind of hunting as crude and brutal don’t have a clue how sophisticated the skills of atlatl hunters are. We are a dedicated, skilled and ethical group of hunters, and I am proud to belong to it.
What I’ve learned in the field
I have killed several deer, a dozen or more wild boar, fish and small game with the atlatl. The atlatl is most effective at 20 yards or less. It has the energy to kill at longer distances, but accuracy drops the farther you get from the target, and it gets more accurate the closer you get, which is true of every hunting implement.
Its short range is a limitation, but it has advantages too. An atlatl can be held in the ready position for a long time, and the dart can be aimed at the deer as it approaches. From the deer’s point of view the dart doesn’t seem to move, because from the end it is so small and the movement so gradual. When the dart is thrown there is little noise and very little motion to startle the deer. I get the atlatl up into launching position before the deer sees me, keep the dart aimed at his eyes until he looks away, then shoot. It is easy to use an atlatl from a tree stand, a ground blind, or still-hunting; cover matters when you’re on the ground, but a tree trunk will do just fine.
Atlatls can be shot safely in almost any direction because of their limited range, and darts seldom ricochet. They can’t go off accidentally. Darts carry more impact and momentum than arrows and make a larger hole, so the deer is usually easier to recover. I have seen razor-sharp darts go completely through the skull of a wild boar, sever the spinal cord, or go right through the shoulder blade of a deer. The seven-foot ash shaft I use is 9/16 inch thick and weighs half a pound.
Practice like a hunter
Many target shooters practice on an unusually large target set farther away than a hunter should shoot, with light cane darts that may weigh as little as 3 ounces. People who see them may get the wrong idea of how the atlatl is used for hunting. I practice on very small objects at distances I know I can hit: objects about the size of apples, at about 10 yards on average, with darts of about 8 ounces. I set up a tree stand with a 3-D deer target at a reasonable range, standing in a quartering-away position.
Every hunter chooses his equipment, gets familiar with it, practices, and does what it takes to have confidence that his shot will be lethal. It’s no different with the atlatl than with a shotgun, muzzleloader or stick bow. I have reached that level of confidence and competence. I am first and foremost an educator, and I can teach anyone who wants to use an atlatl how to get there. Using a 3-D target and my equipment, I can teach most people to use the atlatl effectively in a few hours, so they can go home and practice.
To other hunters
If you have decided against the atlatl, ask yourself if you really know enough about it to pass judgment, or whether it’s a lack of understanding. Each of us, whatever we hunt with, is in a minority. Together we make up a larger voting bloc. So in spite of any doubts about my wish to hunt with an atlatl, I would hope that all of us who hunt and fish would stand together. If you are not interested in atlatl hunting, don’t worry about us. We will cause you no harm.
To a reporter who found the idea funny
One only needs to see an atlatl wielded by an expert at close range to change one’s mind. The atlatl gets far more accurate and deadly as the user gets closer to the target. Its limits at long distance mean the hunter has to develop more skill to get close enough for an effective shot. That’s a good thing for Pennsylvania sportsmen and women. A good challenge never hurt anyone.
It will create a new breed of hunter who must have an intimate awareness of nature to succeed. With a rifle, a hunter can saunter into the woods smoking a cigarette and talking loudly to his buddies and still come home with venison. The atlatl hunter must become part of the background of the wilderness. Details must be attended to, and skills must be learned and practiced. Many will try it and give it up, but for every one who does, there will be those like me who are drawn by the challenge and master the skills.
To those who call it cruel
One thing I have learned as a hunter is that prey animals don’t come to their end by falling asleep in the gentle arms of Mother Nature. You learn this the first time you see a pair of coyotes take a fawn. The human hunter is just another of the predators that walk the earth. Whether we use an atlatl, a bow or a gun, or let the deer die a natural death, it ultimately meets its end. To those who think atlatl hunters will be crueler than hunters with guns or bows, I ask: think of how the deer that survive the human hunter will meet their end. And there is no crueler death than for a deer to be hit by a car and left in the ditch.
To the legislature
Atlatl darts kill big game more quickly and more surely than arrows, and the larger projectile makes it more likely the animal is recovered. The idea that the atlatl is less humane than other weapons has no data behind it. I base this on experiments I have been part of for the last 14 years. Bows and arrows are also “primitive” weapons, and they kill in exactly the same way.
What Pennsylvania would gain
- A new outdoor sport for people who enjoy the atlatl.
- Out-of-state hunting licenses, since Pennsylvania would be the only state in the Northeast allowing the atlatl for deer.
- New hunters: people who otherwise don’t hunt may be drawn in by a new skill to learn.
- Sharper hunting skills, because with an atlatl you must pay attention to every detail.
- A better understanding and appreciation of the people who hunted in Pennsylvania in prehistoric times.
