Bob wrote this in 2010. Fishing laws change: always check your state’s current rules before you go.
Fishing laws for the most part don’t say whether atlatls are legal or not. Almost all fishing regulations are state laws written before the revival of the atlatl, which has happened only in the last 20 or so years. By accident, regulations either allow or forbid atlatls for fishing.
In Georgia, for example, the law says spears may be used for fishing only when the shooter is completely submerged in the water. I suppose you could shoot an atlatl underwater, but I think it would be difficult. The Georgia law was written for spear guns, but by an accident of wording the atlatl may not be used.
In Florida, however, atlatl darts are by definition “gigs,” and because they are hand-thrown, the regulations allow atlatls for flounder, sheepshead, gar and several other fish. Many of us atlatl fishermen and women have bought Florida fishing licenses and fished there, and game wardens who checked our equipment found nothing wrong with it.
Often the regulation can be read either way. I have avoided fishing where the law clearly forbids spears, but where it says spearfishing is legal, I have taken that to allow atlatls and harpoons. I’ve stopped asking enforcement officers, because their easy answer is always “no,” even when they don’t know the real answer. Sometimes it takes a lot of research to find out. That is especially true in New York State, where there are many exceptions depending on time, place and species.
It would be a good thing for atlatl enthusiasts if one state or another would specifically allow atlatls and harpoons in a season for, say, carp, gar, bowfin and suckers. It would do almost nothing to these fish, some of them invasive, but it would offer a new sport and sell a few fishing licenses. People might even come from out of state, especially for atlatl fishing rallies. I know I would sponsor one.
